War memorial could be removed as safety fears spark bitter row
Plus: Restaurant forced to lose outdoor service unit and revamp planned for historic pub
Hello and welcome to the midweek edition of The Southport Lead.
Today we look over to Scarisbrick where an extraordinary row could see the removal of a memorial paying tributes to dozens of people who lost their lives at war.
As warnings over safety on the pavement surround the monument contribute to an argument over who should be responsible for maintaining it, residents are demanding the matter be resolved - but so far it doesn’t like that simple.
Elsewhere, we have news of one planning decision which will help the future of a historic town centre pub and another which will force a popular village restaurant to remove a unit offering outdoor service - at a time when surrounding businesses are thriving in part because of growth in popularity of European style outdoor eat
Villagers defiant over potential loss of war memorial amid ‘safety’ warning
By Elliot Jessett and Jamie Lopez
A much-loved First Word War Memorial is at risk of being removed after trustees of a village hall raised concerns about public safety.
The monument is located on the grounds of The Venue, formerly known as Scarisbrick Village Hall, and was funded by the local community but has become the centre-point of a row between the parish council and the hall’s trustees.
As part of the agreement to situate the monument, Scarisbrick Parish Council said it would maintain it and take responsibility for its upkeep. However, the trustees of the village hall have accused the council of failing in its duty and said they have been forced to issue a removal notice.
John Herbert is a resident of Scarisbrick and was actively involved in setting up the memorial in 2014. The idea was to add to the other two memorials in the parish which – located on the grounds of a Catholic church and an Anglican church – and provide a non-denominational space where everyone would feel comfortable visiting.
Furthermore, after some meticulous researching, John and his colleagues found there were 65 Scarisbrick resident who died during the First World War – half of those had not been named on the existing memorials.
John said: “We examined a series of sources including regimental records, newspaper reports and stuff like that. We also managed to get hold of personal items such as letters and photographs and we finally decided to create a book to further commemorate the sacrifice of those men. You can find that in the local churches and and in the library.
“Scarisbrick isn’t blessed with much public open space, but the village hall was such an area and a place which was held in trust and actually registered with the Charity Commission. The area we looked at was perfectly placed and lay just underneath some beautiful cherry trees. It is a nice, pretty spot which felt appropriately respectful.”
“The parish council on their part gave an undertaking to maintain the memorial, but I would stress here, this wasn’t the parish council’s memorial. This is the community’s memorial.
“For nine years, the memorial has stood in pride of place and is registered with the War Memorials Trust, which can be accessed at the Imperial War Museum. It was also installed in accordance with guidelines from the National Association of Monumental Masons.
“This was all done in order for the community to honour its war heroes – in a building that they funded and which is held in trust for their benefit – the threat of removing that is just wrong.”
It is understood the village hall trustees issued a formal notice to the parish council on July 11 and gave it 28 days to remove the memorial.
Parish councillor Chris Berks said: “At the time when the monument was installed, there was an agreement between the parish council and the village hall trustees that the parish council would maintain the monument and the path, so that the community can benefit from it being there.
“Unfortunately, it looks like the village hall are now intending on removing the memorial. However, the parish council would seek to resolve this amicably with the trustees of the venue and we’re actively seeking an agreement so that we can repair the path and restore the monument back to its original condition.
“The parish council is committed to doing that. There’s absolutely no reason why we would do anything other than maintain that that memorial as originally agreed and we will do whatever is required to achieve that.”
The Local Democracy Reporting Service (LDRS) contacted the chair of trustees for the The Venue and was directed to the notice served to the parish council – made public on social media – and a note displayed near to the war memorial. Stuck to the metal railings put up around the monument, the note states: “This beautiful monument was placed here to remember the sacrifices of all of our past and present members of the armed forces.
“At the time it was placed by Scarisbrick Parish council they promised to maintain the monument and path. Despite repeated requests for the path to be fixed it has now become a serious safety issue with most of the flags cracked, uneven and able to be lifted away from the floor completely.
“The charity trustees have sent letters and emails to Scarisbrick Parish council but have not yet had any acknowledgement or reply, so we have had to spend our own time and money erecting a safety fence to prevent any member of the public injuring themselves.”
The note adds: “Our primary concern has to be safety, but since having cameras installed, we have noticed the monument gets next to no visitors and have suggested it should be somewhere it is seen everyday by lots of people so our armed forces can be remembered all of the time as they should be.
“We understand there will be people who disagree with our actions but would these same people be happy if they or a member of their family injure themselves on this path?”
West Lancashire MP Ashley Dalton has added her support to those working to ensure the monument is retained in its current place. She said she attended a recent parish council meeting on the issue and there was a consensus to see the war memorial protected and the hall better used as a community facility.
However, no trustees attended despite being invited. Ms Dalton said: “The meeting resolved that Scarisbrick Parish Council would contact the Village Hall Trustees and offer to repair the paving elements of the war memorial, as this was the reason identified by the Village Hall for requesting the removal of the memorial and the paving, and thereby removing any need for it to be removed or relocated.
“The parish council also resolved to contact the War Memorials Trust and The British Legion to seek support and to explore legal advice on the matter of the war memorial.
“However, this weekend I learned from local residents that the trustees of the village hall are planning to remove the war memorial even if pavement is repaired.
“I am writing to the trustees of Scarisbrick Village Hall outlining my concerns about the maintenance and the running of the hall and to express the strength of public opinion about the hall and their plans for the war memorial. I am also asking the trustees to meet with me to discuss these issues and their plans.”
On Tuesday, the MP and concerned members of the public gathered outside the monument to send a message to the trustees showing how strongly they believe it should be retained.
For John Herbert, the details of the impasse are secondary and must be resolved because the memorial is too important to be lost. He said: “I know that the public were never consulted if they wanted their memorial removed from the grounds, which are held in trust for their benefit for which they raised the funds. Not one word.
“I do know the anger those people are now feeling.My personal feelings have gone through a whole gamut. First of all, I saw the the notice and my first reaction is, I don’t believe this. I was incredulous.
“It’s a little bit going through the process of grief in a lot of ways. Disbelief to start with, then anger, real anger. I’ve gone beyond that now, and it’s a feeling of sadness.
“The fact that memorials exist reflects the values and the priorities of the community that erected them. We should be honouring these young lads. They served and they made the ultimate sacrifice to safeguard the freedom we now enjoy. What does it say about us if that memorial is removed. Who is anyone to say it must be removed.”
Recommended reading
The plight of the Seventy Ninth Group, which is undergoing liquidation and facing criminal investigation, has been featured previously in this newsletter. The Times is now reporting that the Financial Conduct Authority was warned about concerns involving the company four months before police raid took place.
A huge well done is deserved to everybody involved in organising the charity match at Southport FC last Sunday. More than 3,000 people turned out to watch and the event was covered in this ITV News segment. There’s also pictures here courtesy of Liverpool World.
Planning decisions see restaurant lose outdoor unit and historic pub given fresh look
By Jamie Lopez
The new operators of a historic pub will be allowed to carry out an external refurbishment - but a village restaurant will be told to remove an outdoor unit.
Sefton Council this week issued decisions on the two planning applications with a positive outcome for the Hoghton Arms and a setback for Ainsdale’s Dolce Vita.
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to The Southport Lead to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.